Bush Winch Vs Electric Winch

Winches are useful devices that are typically paired with heavy-duty vehicles like ATVs, UTVs, trucks, etc., and are used for hauling heavy loads and vehicular rescue. There are various types of winches available in the market. Bush winch and electrical winch are two popular types of winches. The following article focuses on explaining and comparing the different aspects of the bush winch and electrical winch for a better understanding of the readers.

Bush Winch[1] is a company that is based in Western Australia. As winches are the most obvious choice for vehicular rescue, the company tried to design an alternative to the traditional winch that runs on electricity, as there have been many cases where off-roaders could not rescue their vehicles due to battery failure.

Bush winches are also known as wheel winches as it operates by drawing power from one of the vehicle’s wheels. The original design of the bush winch was made for the famous six-stud Japanese wheel ends. The creators of bush winch have been developing the design over the years, and the more recent 2019 Series II is a two-piece design that is made in a way to fit a wider range of vehicles.

The bush winch is attached to the wheel of the vehicle with the help of wheel nuts and bolts that are specially designed for this purpose. These nuts and bolts replace the original nuts and bolts permanently. Unlike other winches, the bush winch features two drums and uses two ropes for winching, which are placed on each rope. Bush winches are normally placed on the rear axle of the vehicle, with the two being guided by the rope guides attached to the front wheels.

An electric winch, on the other hand, is a type of winch that operates with the help of electric motors that are built inside of it. The winch motor draws direct current electricity that is supplied by the electrical system of the vehicle. An electrical winch is mainly used for placing, pulling, and lifting heavy goods and items.

Electrical winches are best suitable for towing and hauling applications, as a result of which, in most cases, are used in such industries that involve the movement of goods from one place to another, like landscaping, telecommunications, and power industries.

Electrical winches are available in different sizes and designs. Generally, electrical winches feature a two-speed engine. A basic electrical winch has a horizontal rotating drum with a cable or rope attached to it. The cable is also attached to the motor of the winch.

For the easy release of the winch rope, a gear lever is also present, which assists in turning the spool to release the cable. The average length of the winch cable on an electrical winch is around thirty metres. Electrical winches also come with dynamic brakes that provide easy control over the winch and a remote control that allows the user to operate the winch over long distances.

Bush Winch

Bush winches are generally attached to one of the wheels of the vehicle with the help of specially made nuts and bolts. In comparison to electrical winches, bush winches do not run by drawing power from the vehicle’s battery or the electrical system. Rather it is powered by the vehicle’s wheel itself.

A bush winch features two ropes that are placed on top of the two drums. Therefore, the winching action is done with the assistance of two wheels. Therefore, when the wheel of the vehicle rotates, the extra slack is spooled up in the winch line, which moves the vehicle steadily.

Bush winches are very helpful for such people who like to go solo travelling, as they can recover their vehicle in case of any problematic situation on their own. Recovering a vehicle with the help of a bush winch is very easy. All one needs to do is attach the winch drum by twisting it on the nuts and then winding the rope around any nearby object.

PROS

CONS

Electric Winch

Electric winches are mainly used for pulling, lifting, and positioning automobiles, trucks, or other such types of equipment and recusing them when they are stuck in an uncomfortable situation. They are often paired with off-road vehicles like ATVs and UTVs, boats, and cranes.

An electrical winch, on average, can handle a load of 500 pounds to 2000 pounds. As we know that electrical winches are motor operated, and different electrical winches feature different motors with different capacities, which are designed for dealing with wide ranges of weight loads.

The more recent versions of electrical winches feature planetary gears or elliptical gears. These gears are called so, as their mechanism involves one small gear rotating around a larger gear, just like the planets rotate around the sun. Electrical winches are generally mounted on the rear end of the vehicle and can provide an engine performance that ranges from one-third horsepower to fifty horsepower.

Most ATV and UTV winches operate by DC that they draw from the battery of the off-road vehicle itself. On the other hand, trailer and truck winches operate by drawing DC power directly from the electrical system. Although these winches run on electricity, they do not use a lot of electricity as the gear system executes the greater share of work.

If you wish to explore more on electric winches, I recommend you go through the following articles: PTO Winch Vs Electric Winch, Hydraulic or Electric Winch, best electric winches, Hand vs electric winch

PROS

CONS

Summary

Therefore, if you are planning to buy a winch for your heavy-duty vehicle, you can buy either of the two types of winches mentioned. Bush winches and electrical winches are used and recommended by many off-roaders. Both come with their advantages and disadvantages. The type of winch you use depends on the type of vehicle you are using, how often you would use the winch, and the type of application.

References