Badland vs Smittybilt Winch - Is Apex better than a Gen3?

A winch is like a strong helper that uses a rope to pull your vehicle out when it’s stuck. With so many brands out there, picking the right one can be tricky. Smittybilt and Badland are two big names that many people trust because they offer good quality at fair prices. But each brand has its own special features, so it’s important to look closely and choose the one that fits your needs best.

Badland Vs Smittybilt

Brand name	Smittybilt	Badland
Origin	USA	China
Winch Capacity	Up to 17500 lbs	Up to 12000 lbs
Wireless Remote	Yes	Yes
Type of Rope	Synthetic/Steel	Synthetic/Steel
Waterproof	Yes (Specific Models)	Limited Models
Warranty Period	Limited Lifetime	90 days, Extended Available

Smittybilt

Smittybilt[1] was started in 1956 when Basil “Smitty” Smith opened his workshop. He was passionate about off-roading and started creating quality gear for trucks and Jeeps. His winches quickly gained a reputation for durability and performance among off-road enthusiasts, helping to grow Smittybilt from a one-man operation into the trusted brand it is today.

It started with a focus on four-wheel-drive vehicles and has since expanded to a wide array of off-roading and Jeep accessories, with winches being a significant part of their product line.

Known for innovation and quality, Smittybilt has built a loyal following among off-road enthusiasts.

Product Range

They’ve got a whole bunch of winches you can choose from. Some are strong enough to pull 9,500 lbs suitable for smaller tasks and for those with heavier loads, Smittybilt offers winches that can handle up to 17,500 lbs – ideal for large vehicles and more demanding recoveries.

They’re particularly famous for their robust winch series like the XRC, the waterproof X2O, and the cutting-edge GEN3, which comes with a state-of-the-art control box and a synthetic rope option.

Their product range also includes a variety of accessories and upgrades, like wireless remotes for easier operation and winch covers for protection.

It’s this mix of basic to advanced options that makes Smittybilt a go-to for both casual off-road enthusiasts and hardcore adventurers who need reliable equipment that can take on tough conditions and challenging terrains.

Pricing

You can expect to pay anywhere from about $300 to $700 for a Smittybilt winch. This might sound like a lot, but these winches are made to last and do a lot of heavy lifting so it compensates for the price they are asking it for.

Who Should Buy This ?

If you’re someone who’s always out there taking on tough trails or if you need a winch that’s going to stand up to a lot of use, then Smittybilt is a good choice. They’re built tough, so they’re great for anyone who needs a winch that’s as ready for adventure as they are.

Badland

Started in 2010, Originally Badland[2] Winches were manufactured in China by winches manufacturing firms called Ningbo Lianda Winch Co and Ningbo Antai Winches Technology Co. The brand “Badland” was created by Harbor Freight[3] Tools and made their debut in the off-roading equipment market to provide affordable yet reliable winching options.

Although the specific year of introduction is not widely publicized, Harbor Freight has been known for its value-driven tools and equipment, and Badland Winches are no exception. This line of winches was developed with the aim of offering a cost-effective solution for off-roaders, without sacrificing quality or performance.

They’ve gained popularity primarily due to their value proposition, providing functional and sturdy winches at a lower price point.

Product Range

Badland has a solid lineup of winches for you to pick from. Starting with models that can tug 2,500 lbs, perfect for light jobs and ATV adventures, all the way up to the heavy-duty ones that can pull a hefty 12,000 lbs like the Apex, making them great for bigger rigs and tougher situations.

They’ve made a name for themselves with durable winches that come at a more affordable price point. While they might not have the extensive series names like some brands, their winches are straightforward, reliable, and get the job done without fuss.

Plus, Badland winches often come with handy features like wireless remotes for convenient operation, and they offer both synthetic and steel cable options to suit your preference.

This blend of practicality, affordability, and reliability is what makes Badland a solid choice for folks who enjoy off-roading without wanting to spend a fortune, as well as for those who might not hit the trails often but still want a dependable winch ready when needed.

Pricing

The price for Badland winches ranges from approximately $100 for the more basic, lower-capacity models, to around $600 for the high-capacity, feature-rich versions. This makes them an affordable option for a wide range of budgets.

Who should buy this ?

Badland winches are particularly well-suited for occasional off-roaders, DIY enthusiasts, and those new to winching who seek reliable performance without a high investment. They offer the essential functionality needed for standard recovery tasks, making them a popular choice among budget-conscious consumers looking for value.

Badland vs Smittybilt - A Deeper Dive

Pull Capacity

Smittybilt: Smittybilt’s lineup is quite diverse, offering winches with capacities that start at 9,500 lbs for those smaller, more routine tasks. For those who need more muscle, Smittybilt steps up to the plate with winches capable of handling up to 17,500 lbs.

They are available to be used for simple vehicle recoveries[4] to moving heavy loads that demand significant power.

Badland: When it comes to Badland winches, they focus on the core needs of most off-roaders, offering winches with capacities from 7,500 lbs up to 12,000 lbs. This range is perfect for the majority of recovery situations you might encounter on the trails. Whether you’re pulling your ATV out of a tight spot or need to haul a heavier vehicle, Badland provides reliable options that cater to the essential requirements of off-road recovery without going overboard.

Quality

Smittybilt: Smittybilt is synonymous with top-notch quality in the winching world. Their winches are built with durability in mind, featuring rugged construction of steel that can withstand harsh environments and challenging recoveries. Smittybilt’s commitment to excellence means their winches are designed not just to perform well but to last, ensuring that users can rely on them time and again, no matter the conditions.

Badland: Badland winches are recognized for their solid and reliable build, providing effective winching capabilities that meet the demands of most recovery situations. While they may not pack all the high-end features of premium brands, Badland focuses on what’s most important: performance and reliability. This approach ensures that Badland winches deliver where it matters, offering a dependable solution for off-roaders looking for quality without the high price tag.

Remote

Smittybilt: Smittybilt takes the winching experience up a notch with their intuitive wireless remotes. These remotes are all about making your winching tasks more convenient and safer, allowing you to operate the winch from a safe distance. This feature is particularly useful in challenging or potentially hazardous recovery situations, where maintaining a safe distance is crucial.

Badland: Badland winches come equipped with wireless remotes that provide a reliable range of operation, ensuring you can manage your winching tasks from a safe distance. While the remotes may be more straightforward and less feature-rich compared to those offered by Smittybilt, they cover all the necessary functions to control the winch effectively.

Rope

Smittybilt: Smittybilt offers a versatile selection of ropes for their winches, allowing users to choose between the classic durability of steel ropes and the modern lightweight advantage of synthetic ropes. This choice lets users tailor their winching setup to their specific needs and preferences, whether they prioritize the ruggedness of steel or the safer, easier-to-handle characteristics of synthetic rope.[5]

Badland: Badland provides both steel and synthetic rope options across their winch range, catering to the diverse needs of off-roaders. Whether you’re looking for the traditional toughness of steel rope or the lighter, more user-friendly synthetic alternative, Badland has you covered.

This flexibility allows for effective adaptation to different recovery situations, ensuring that users can choose the rope that best suits their particular winching needs while maintaining Badland’s focus on delivering value and consistent reliability.

Price

Smittybilt: Smittybilt’s winches, known for their high-quality build and advanced functionalities, are priced to reflect their premium status in the market. The cost for a Smittybilt winch typically starts around $300 and can go up to $700 or more, especially for models equipped with the latest features like wireless remotes and synthetic ropes.

Badland: Badland winches, on the other hand, are all about bringing value to the table. Their prices are more budget-friendly, with entry-level models available for around $100, and the more feature-rich, higher-capacity models capped at about $600. This pricing strategy makes Badland winches an attractive option for hobbyists, occasional off-roaders, and those who need a reliable winch without the hefty price tag.

Waterproof

Smittybilt: Smittybilt has engineered certain winch models to offer exceptional waterproofing, making them highly resilient against water ingress. These models come with IP 68 (Ingress Protection) ratings[6] and some even with IP 66(Highest order rating) that signify their ability to withstand not just splashes, but also continuous exposure to water, ensuring reliable performance even under heavy rain or when fording through water obstacles.

This level of waterproofing is particularly beneficial for off-roaders who frequently encounter wet conditions and need their equipment to remain unfazed by the external conditions.

Badland: Badland winches include models with water resistance features, aimed at providing protection against moderate water exposure. While they might not all have the high IP ratings like IP 66 of some Smittybilt models, Badland winches are built to endure the occasional splash or short-term submersion without compromising functionality.

This makes them well-suited for the average off-road enthusiast who might face wet conditions but doesn’t necessarily require a winch with extensive waterproofing for extreme environments.

Warranty

Smittybilt: Offers a limited lifetime warranty on mechanical parts and a 5-year warranty on electrical components.

Badland: Provides a 90-day warranty with options for extended coverage. You also get the possibility of extending coverage for additional peace of mind.

Which One to Choose Now?

The decision between Smittybilt and Badland winches boils down to your specific needs.

If you require a winch for heavy-duty pulling and value long-term durability and advanced features, Smittybilt is your go-to.

For those on a budget or with lighter winching requirements, Badland offers a cost-effective and reliable solution.

Conclusion

In comparing Smittybilt and Badland winches, Smittybilt stands out for its wide range of high-capacity, durable winches with advanced features, backed by strong warranties, ideal for serious off-roaders. Badland offers affordability and reliability with practical features, suitable for occasional use and those on a budget. Your choice depends on your off-roading frequency, load requirements, and budget, with Smittybilt catering to heavy-duty needs and Badland providing value for standard recoveries.

References